Comprehensive Legal Solutions
For Individuals And Businesses

Ninth Circuit Addresses Appellate Finality, Minority-Stockholder Control, and Worker-Notice Liability in Island Air Bankruptcy Litigation

On Behalf of | Nov 9, 2026 | Firm News

On September 29, 2026, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit issued a wide-ranging bankruptcy-related decision arising from the collapse of Hawaii Island Air, Inc. (“Island Air”). In Kane v. PaCap Aviation Fin., LLC (In re Haw. Island Air, Inc.), 2026 U.S. App. LEXIS 29786, 2026 WL 2919183 (9th Cir. 2026), the court affirmed in part, reversed in part, and remanded consolidated litigation involving Island Air’s bankruptcy trustee, two employee unions, and several of the airline’s former owners, officers, directors, and affiliated entities.

The decision addresses several issues of interest to bankruptcy, corporate, and employment-law practitioners, including appellate jurisdiction after withdrawal of the bankruptcy reference, a Chapter 7 trustee’s standing to pursue fiduciary-duty claims, the circumstances under which a minority stockholder may owe fiduciary duties under Delaware law, and individual liability under the WARN Act.

This post does not address the Ninth Circuit’s rulings under Hawai’i’s Dislocated Workers Act, which interprets a statute specific to Hawai’i.

Background

Island Air operated interisland flights in Hawai’i. In 2013, the Lawrence J. Ellison Revocable Trust acquired the airline through Ohana Airline Holdings, LLC (“Ohana”). In 2016, entities controlled by local businessman Jeffrey Au acquired a two-thirds interest in Island Air, while Ohana retained a one-third interest. Ohana also held a warrant allowing it to acquire a majority of Island Air’s shares for $12,000. Ellison-affiliated entities remained significant lenders and aircraft lessors to Island Air.

Island Air continued to suffer losses. On November 9, 2017, the airline informed its employees that it would cease operations the next day, leaving employees without their final paychecks. Elizabeth Kane, the Chapter 7 trustee (“Trustee”), joined with the Air Line Pilots Association and Hawaii Teamsters and Allied Workers, Local 996 (collectively the “Unions”), in bringing adversary proceedings against former owners, directors, officers, lenders, and affiliated entities. The plaintiffs asserted claims under the federal Worker Adjustment and Retraining Notification Act (“WARN Act”) and Hawai’i’s Dislocated Workers Act (“DWA”), together with fiduciary duty and bankruptcy related equitable claims.

After a month-long trial, the jury returned a mixed verdict that imposed liability on certain Au-affiliated defendants. The district court also resolved legal and equitable issues through post-trial rulings and a lengthy written decision. The resulting appeal required the Ninth Circuit to address both threshold jurisdictional questions and the merits of multiple claims.

Appellate Jurisdiction and Finality After Withdrawal of the Bankruptcy Reference

The first question was whether the Ninth Circuit had jurisdiction even though aspects of Island Air’s broader bankruptcy case remained pending. The district court had withdrawn the bankruptcy reference and adjudicated the consolidated adversary proceedings itself.

The Ninth Circuit concluded that the amended judgment was final for purposes of 28 U.S.C. § 1291 because it ended the withdrawn civil proceeding on the merits. In the majority’s view, the remaining matters involved enforcement of the judgment or administration of the underlying bankruptcy estate rather than unresolved issues of merit in the withdrawn proceeding. That conclusion reflects the treatment of finality in bankruptcy litigation. A bankruptcy case may contain numerous discrete controversies, and an order may be appealable when it finally resolves the relevant proceeding even though the larger bankruptcy case continues. The Ninth Circuit has nevertheless recognized that, when appellate jurisdiction arises under Section 1291 following proceedings in the district court, the court must apply Section 1291’s finality requirements rather than automatically importing the more flexible framework governing direct bankruptcy appeals. The Ninth Circuit emphasized that treating the entire chapter 7 case as the relevant unit for finality would risk indefinite delay and potentially make meaningful review impossible, particularly because subsequent claim objections and distributions could rest on the legal conclusions under review. Judge Forrest did dissent, arguing that no final judgment existed because unresolved bankruptcy matters remained or because issues remained even within the adversary proceeding. Judge Forrest maintained that the court should have issued a limited remand for the district court to consider Rule 54(b) certification.

The Chapter 7 Trustee’s Standing to Pursue Fiduciary Duty Claims

The Ninth Circuit next addressed whether the Trustee had standing to pursue the fiduciary-duty claims. A bankruptcy trustee generally stands in the debtor corporation’s shoes and may assert claims that belonged to the corporation when the bankruptcy petition was filed. The trustee ordinarily may not pursue claims belonging solely to individual creditors.

Applying that distinction, the court concluded that the Trustee could pursue claims alleging injury to Island Air, including allegations that fiduciaries harmed the company while it was insolvent. Such claims are property of the bankruptcy estate rather than direct claims belonging exclusively to creditors. By contrast, individual creditors of an insolvent Delaware corporation generally cannot assert direct fiduciary-duty claims against the corporation’s directors merely because the corporation is insolvent.

Minority-Stockholder Fiduciary Duties Under Delaware Law

One of the decision’s most significant corporate-law rulings concerned whether Ohana could owe fiduciary duties despite owning only 33.33% of Island Air during the relevant period.

Under Delaware law, stockholders ordinarily do not owe fiduciary duties merely because they own shares. A stockholder may, however, become a controlling stockholder and assume fiduciary obligations either by owning a majority of the corporation’s voting power or by exercising actual control over the corporation’s business and affairs. A minority position, standing alone, is insufficient. The proper inquiry focuses on whether the stockholder actually dominated corporate conduct.

The Ninth Circuit concluded that the evidence was sufficient to permit a jury to determine whether Ohana exercised actual control. The evidence included Ohana’s warrant rights, financial and aircraft-leasing relationships involving Ellison-affiliated entities, access to information concerning Island Air’s financial condition, relationships with advisers and vendors, and the affiliated entities’ ability to provide or withhold resources important to the airline’s continued operations. The court therefore reversed the entry of judgment as a matter of law for Ohana and Lawrence Investments, LLC on two fiduciary-duty counts and remanded for further proceedings.

Importantly, the decision does not establish that every minority stockholder with contractual rights or economic influence is a controller. Delaware law still requires a fact-intensive evaluation of actual power, whether exercised over the corporation generally or in connection with a particular transaction. Rather, the practical lesson is that courts may look beyond formal ownership percentages to the stockholder’s financing relationships, contractual rights, access to information, operational leverage, and practical influence over corporate decision-making.

Individual WARN Act Liability and the Damages Remand

The court also affirmed the amended judgment relieving Jeffrey Au of individual liability on the WARN Act claim. The WARN Act generally requires a covered employer to provide 60 days’ notice of a qualifying plant closing or mass layoff and authorizes up to 60 days of back pay for a violation. On a fiduciary-duty claim identified as Count VI, the Ninth Circuit vacated the nominal-damages award and remanded for a new trial on damages. The court concluded that the evidence concerning Island Air’s deteriorating net worth supplies a basis from which damages could be responsibly estimated rather than limited to a nominal amount. The appellate disposition also left additional equitable issues to be addressed on remand.

Key Takeaways

The key takeaways from this case are plentiful. First, when a district court withdraws the bankruptcy reference and fully adjudicates the resulting civil proceeding, the judgment may be final under 28 U.S.C. § 1291 even if administrative matters remain pending in the broader bankruptcy case. Second, a Chapter 7 trustee has standing to pursue fiduciary-duty claims alleging harms to the corporation, but there remains a distinction between corporate claims and claims belonging exclusively to creditors. Third, minority ownership does not foreclose fiduciary duties under Delaware law where evidence permits a finding of actual control through contractual rights, financial leverage, insider access, and business relationships. Fourth, warrant rights, financing arrangements, access to information, aircraft leases, and the ability to provide or withhold essential resources may collectively support a finding of actual control. Lastly, in fiduciary-duty litigation under Delaware law, where wrongdoing and injury are established, evidence providing a responsible basis for estimating damages may support more than a nominal award.

Archives