Mark Buchheim (“Buchheim”) and his former wife, Tatjana Luethi, supplied funds to buy and remodel homes through their company, Prima Impressa, LLC. Meanwhile, Gustavo Anaya (“Anaya”), and his family Olivia Anaya Valenzuela, Maria Anaya Taglioli, of United Home Buyers of America, Inc. carried out the actual purchase and remodel of the homes. For approximately twenty years, the Buchheim funded Anaya’s real estate projects at a twenty percent (20%) interest rate. The parties’ dispute began with two properties. First, the Cleveland Property, which Anaya owed $36,000.00 to Buchheim on; second, the Rose Property, which Anaya owed $388,928.00 to Buchheim on. In March 2017, the parties consolidated the amounts owed into a written promissory note totaling $424,928.00, secured by a second deed of trust on the Rose Property (the “Note”).
Thereafter, the parties disagreed on how to remodel the Rose Property and the business relationship between the families deteriorated. Eventually, the parties agreed that Buchheim would purchase the Rose Property from Anaya, complete the remodel, and sell the home. This agreement between the parties included a covenant that Buchheim would not sue to recover on the Note. The parties closed on the Rose Property in January 2018 for $1,550,000.00. To consummate the transaction, Buchheim secured a loan and transferred $1,550,000.00 in escrow to the Chicago Title Company. In an unusual escrow process, which typically flows money from the buyer to the seller, the Chicago Title then wired $471,381.46 back to the buyer Buchheim, representing repayment of the Note, with accrued interest.
Despite the transfer of the Rose Property, Buchheim filed suit on February 19, 2018, asserting 12 causes of action, including breach of contract, fraud, and rescission of the covenant not to sue. During his deposition, Buchheim repeatedly admitted that he received the $471,381.46 escrow payment, but he also remained fervent in his belief that Anaya never paid him what was owed under the Note. Anaya moved for summary judgment. The trial court granted Anaya’s motion for summary judgment, concluding that the Note had been fully paid and that the covenant not to sue independently barred Buchheim’s claims. Buchheim appealed.
A Court of Appeal for the Second District considered (1) whether a triable issue of material fact existed regarding the repayment of the Note due to Buchheim’s deposition testimony, and (2) whether Buchheim could assert additional alleged damages—including closing costs, late fees, delinquent mortgage charges, and unpaid property taxes—that he had not presented to the trial court. The Appellate Court ultimately determined that no triable issue existed because the undisputed $471,381.46 escrow transfer back to Buchheim fully repaid the Note. The Court also held that because Buchheim did not raise his alternative damages theories to the trial court, he forfeited those arguments on appeal. Buchheim v. Anaya, 122 Cal.App.5th 877, 884-85 (2026).
The Court of Appeal held that when undisputed financial records establish repayment, a party’s unexplained personal beliefs to the contrary cannot create a triable issue of material fact. Id. at 884. The Court distinguished its holding in Buchheim from an impermissible appellate determination on the credibility of evidence because the parties agreed on the existence of the $471,381.46 escrow transfer back to Buchheim. Id.’
On review of the record, the Appellate Court determined the Note was worth $471,381.46, and Buchheim received exactly $471,381.46 in escrow on the Rose Property which completely satisfied Anaya’s obligation. Buchheim argued that the escrow payment should not count towards Anaya’s debt because the funds came from money he had placed into escrow to purchase the Rose Property, rather than to pay off the Note. The court rejected that argument because Buchheim not only received the Rose Property, but also received $471,381.46 back from the escrow company.
The Court reasoned this escrow transfer back to Buchheim, “was the same as if Anaya had given Buchheim a discount on the house in the amount Anaya owed Buchheim.” Id. at 882. As such, Buchheim’s, and his former wife Luethi’s, deposition testimony that they had not received the money owed on the Note was inapposite. Their uncorroborated, self-serving deposition testimony did not create a triable issue of fact sufficient to defeat summary judgment in light of the uncontroverted escrow transfer.
The decision in Buchheim emphasizes that a party opposing summary judgment in a financial dispute must identify concrete evidence demonstrating a genuine accounting discrepancy in the record. A mere conviction that funds were not repaid will not create a triable issue where an undisputed transaction establishes that a creditor received the full amount owed, plus interest. In sum, unexplained deposition statements of fervent belief cannot overcome objective and uncontroverted financial records.

